Nov. 22nd, 2005

pecunium: (Default)
Antonin Scalia (of whom I am not fond, mostly because I think him either a sham, or a hypocrite. A clever thinker, but at some level a fake) has said the reason the Court had to interfere with Florida's State Laws, and he had to take part in a case at odds with his entire judicial history; which had a decision at odds with his past history, as written in opinions both under his name and with his concurrance, as well as being and oddity, in that it was specifically (again, against his express philosophy, as stated in public) it had no precedential standing, as well as being decided on issues the appellant didn't raise, and which weren't explored in argument (mostly because the justices had shown a strong tendency in recent years to discount such claims, but this one time they not only decided it was a big deal, but four of them (four, out of five) voted in a way diametrically opposed to their past history on the issue was because Gore made them.

Yep, it was all Gore's fault, ""The election was dragged into the courts by the Gore people. We did not go looking for trouble." He said that at the Time Warner Center last night.

Now, putting aside the entire, "lookng for trouble," thing (and the conflict of interest one might suppose from Thomas having a daughter (IIRC) who worked for Bush, and O' Connor saying that now he was elected (before the brouhaha) that she was glad, because now she could retire) because we can't know (barring the minutes of some secret meeting where they got together and said, "How can we be rid of this troublesome democrat?"), but the first part, the part where he says Gore dragged this into the courts, I have three words.

Bush versus Gore

It's a very simple formula, the person who initiates the suit, gets named first.

Bush versus Gore

Not Gore versus Bush, but

Bush versus Gore.

So who's fault was it?



hit counter

Profile

pecunium: (Default)
pecunium

June 2023

S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11 121314151617
181920212223 24
252627282930 

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jan. 8th, 2026 09:30 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios