pecunium: (Default)
pecunium ([personal profile] pecunium) wrote2004-10-14 03:16 pm

Second hand politics, or maybe third

Patrick, over here Electrolite links to Will Shetterly and some amusing play ensues, on the lines of the story, "What if the North had Won the War". I forget who wrote it, I seem to recall it was published in the Sat. Evening Post.


So go, be amused. It's a much more fun bit of political ranting than I've been doing.





hit counter

Awesome

[identity profile] ammitbeast.livejournal.com 2004-10-14 10:40 pm (UTC)(link)
Shetterly's piece is priceless. Great stuff.

The really disappointing thing, though, is that the ardent Bush supporters just would not get it.

Of course, we're talking about a hypothetical situation. Naturally.

Good thing we don't have to actually live in that alternate universe. Thank Dog we only have to decide whether or not President Gore deserves a second term.

One such story

[identity profile] dsgood.livejournal.com 2004-10-14 11:11 pm (UTC)(link)
It's been done more than once, but this might be the best. From http://uchronia.net:
Churchill, Winston S. "If Lee had not Won the Battle of Gettysburg".
Divergence: 1863
What if: Jeb Stuart reached the battlefield in time to support Pickett's charge. Later, Lee unilaterally freed the slaves and Britain recognized the CSA.
Summary: Musings on how a Confederate defeat at Gettysburg might have prevented the formation of the English-speaking union. Thus, the story could be said to be recursive alternative history.
Comments: A discussion of the credibility of the divergence occurs in Hook's The Hero in History, q.v.

Published: In If It Had Happened Otherwise: Lapses Into Imaginary History, all eds. (ed. J.C. Squire), q.v.; and What Might Have Been? Volume 3: Alternate Wars (eds. Gregory Benford and Martin H. Greenberg), q.v.
Original in: English.
Translation: German by Walter Brumm as "Wenn Lee die Schlacht von Gettysburg nicht gewonnen hätte", in Heyne Science Fiction Magazin #9; and Wenn Napoleon bei Waterloo gewonnen hätte. Und andere abwegige Geschichten (ed. J.C. Squire), Heyne 1999 (3453149114).
Translation: Italian by M. Cristina Pietri as "Se Lee non avesse vinto la battaglia di Gettysburg", in I mondi del possibile (ed. Piergiorgio Nicolazzini), q.v.